Logo
Login
Register

Clerk auth reddit

Clerk auth reddit. Reply reply Hey everyone, not a game dev here but I work for an auth company and we're trying to figure out if we can build more specific features for game devs. Auth0 and Clerk). No frameworks equivalent to Rails, Django, Laravel. For me, this currently feels a bit too experimental - It looks like it requires a bit more time to set up and maintain over package updates. Because of which I’m guessing, it’s not statically generating the pages which it should Because of which I’m guessing, it’s not statically generating the pages which it should Hey everyone, not a game dev here but I work for an auth company and we're trying to figure out if we can build more specific features for game devs. Nextjs frontend Nestjs fastify backend Clerk auth Stripe payment Mongo db Google PubSub I sort of regret for not going with nextjs as a backend because of these 2 reasons: -copying types from backend to frontend is frustrating as fuck and you will lose quite some time with that -CI/CD and Infrastructure work is x2 and it creates a lot of overhead. I wanted to add clerk authentication but is having issues as it is designed for node. But I don't, so I pay the people that do. DISCONTINUED. Apple, Google, Facebook, Twitter, etc) - any access to data Personally I use clerk. This is where your users will be redirected to after a successful authentication and is required to successfully create your OAuth application in the next step. js for a while and tried out Clerk and switched to Supabase in the end as I wanted one system for database, auth and storage. What is the “User” object? The User object contains all account information that describes a Supabase vs Clerk vs Kinde Auth Hey everyone! I'm working on my first RN Expo App and would like to implement authentication for the app if someone has experience with these services. Clerk & other paid providers are always tempting but having a paid service between your business and your users is a big ask. I never got on board. Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download Building a Next. Another thing you may want to consider is how your auth is integrated with your other services. All Clerk hooks and components must be children of the <ClerkProvider> component, which provides active session and user context. Clerk is super easy to set up, however as stated before, you don’t have control over your data. It's closer to a self hosted Azure active directory than anything else. It also demonstrates a basic example of how you could use the getToken() method to retrieve a session token for fetching data from an external resource. Covers many, many use cases, and is very extendable. js is terrifying because it is complex and the documentation may as well not exist. Best way to do auth with Next + Node JS App? Any help or Clerk is really amazing. Vue + Clerk integration. Disclaimer If you think you found a bug in the default configuration, you can open an issue. . I started using it for one of my own personal projects due to how quickly I could get it up and running and plugged into third party auth providers. I'm currently in the process of developing a website and integrating Clerk for authentication. Has support for Supabase, firebase, Hasura integrations making authorization easy to DBs. That's not exclusive to clerk, and is workable with any auth service which exposes a REST endpoint to authenticate using those details. Doing that is way better than any follow along "join me for the next 8 hours as I show you how to make a xyz clone with Next, Tailwind, linode, cloudinary, Prisma, shadcn, RSC, Clerk Auth, TypeScript, Nx Monorepo, and Postgres and then I'll show you how to host it on hostinger and vercel and connect your GitHub account" tutorial on YouTube. r/webdev A chip A close button. I will use the template for json web api backends for B2C and B2B SaaS projects. Authentication for the Web. Internet Culture (Viral) Amazing We have migrated our auth from Clerk to NextAuth v5 News We have updated our auth system from clerk to NextAuth V5, openstatus. js see the Next. I am trying to protect Clerk has a better free tier IMHO, as well as native support for organizations. I’ve been looking but there don’t seem to be any concrete examples/tutorials Advertisement Coins. I got tired of using Next Auth. Let's explore why Clerk has become my preferred option and how it streamlines development. Controversial. Getting auth working is easy, but getting it working correctly and maintainable is hard. Are there any Deno Community driven examples on how to Clerk. Now, let's dive into the code and integrate Clerk authentication into our WunderGraph BFF. i have list of questions because i'm kind of lost. You're relinquishing parts of your auth, user management, and the stewardship of that data to Clerk, a 3rd party company. Or check it out in the app stores I was using clerk auth with react with one of project where backend is Django. Hey guys as the title says any good auth libary other than nextauth? not clerk i want something on the project it self than saas? i like nextauth but i need to use credentials with strategy database so i can delete and deauth as i like and not wait for the jwt to expire. js, two more well-liked authentication libraries for Next. Supabase has done a really good job and it’s very smooth to use. Redwallian • Start by using their server-side API reference to get started. Since Clerk has a great suite of components for Next. Plan and track work Code Review. The Issue here is that if you operate multiple Apps, then you don’t have one shared Authentication but separate Authentication for every single Project. Clerk is an authentication platform providing login via passwords, social identity providers, one-time email or SMS access codes, and multi-factor authentication and basic user management. Create an OAuth application in Clerk. Auth. This step-by-step guide simplifies the process of migrating user authentication from Supabase to Clerk. But you won't have much as much control. I recommend the T3-Stack for setting NextAuth up. Now that you've implemented authentication in your React application using the traditional JWT flow and with Clerk, you can see how easy it is to implement a full-fledged authentication using the latter approach. Basically everything was being swapped out for custom functions and overrides, and the underlying patterns of Next Auth just didn’t feel right to any of the developers. I've been trying to add authentication to a new Next. As the title says, I am looking for a way to integrate Clerk with with my fFlutter app. js Free software comment sorted by Best Top New Controversial Q&A Add a Comment. 3. One of the biggest auth as a service companies. js, Ory, Clerk and others . UX-wise the redirection is a clean cut. Refresh tokens with my backend. Log In / Sign Up; Advertise on Reddit; Shop Hi! Every time I try to use an auth provider, it feels like things become more complicated than building the auth myself. Hey everyone! I built a free boilerplate kit for Next. I'm getting quite lost in the sea of information and plus the added burden of setting up User Managed Access. We have zero affiliation with Clerk (they don’t even know we wrote this 🙂) but we like their tool and we thought this walk-through would be helpful to other developers who have asked us about authentication in the context of Next. I started using Supabase's docs but there isn't enough use Node SDK Middleware. I also took it Hier sollte eine Beschreibung angezeigt werden, diese Seite lässt dies jedoch nicht zu. Add your thoughts and get the conversation going. Long story short Auth0 ≠ Oauth. I have been trying to figure out how to make them work together but there's no documentation out there for my issue. dev Open. Maybe u can share your errors here, or Supabase can help you. Open menu Open navigation Go to Reddit Home. Problem with clerk authentication . Our docs aren't perfect and are going through a major overhaul, but, you'll probably get more functionality in 10min than you could ever dream of w/ auth0. Next-auth supports credentials as a provider but they also stated here that it is intentionally limited to discourage the use of passwords due to the inherent security risks. If a route is protected do the following: Get the user ID from Clerk. Old. All help is appreciated! Share Add a Comment. dev and signing up for a free account. In the lowest paid tier, auth0 stays at 7,000, whereas clerk offers unlimited MAU. js in general), or Clerk if you want to go with an SaaS. While user_id can produce this confusion either a phone number or email connected accounts will be a massive pain, so there is a still a need for a good open source auth solution for next. Your tagline is "more than auth, full user management", yet everything breaks when we rely on the Clerk API for grabbing user data (like usernames) instead of Go check out next-auth (or auth. Skip to content. After signing in, you will be prompted to create a new application within your account. next-auth documentation is mixed information between the old and the new router. 7. js(formerly nextjs), which could end up being a viable alternative when they launch react native support, if you want to host your Hey , I am thinking about using clerk although I don't have a clear idea about it , I mean should I use just with in the front (react) or I have to do some backend, I did some research and I didn't find any real helpful documentation about how to use it with react and express Clerk is a great solution for quickly integrating authentication and custom user profiles into your application. It took me over 2 months to make this video, and I tried super hard to condense it down to the essentials, building up from first principles. 4 (App dir), Supabase and auth-helpers 0. Best way to do auth with Next + Node JS App? Any help or directing me towards a tutorial would be great! Thanks <3 I know how to do it in Node, I've seen it done in NextJS, but I'm not sure how to do them both together comments sorted by Best Top New Controversial Q&A Add a Comment I recently went through this article by NextAuth, and I kinda want to implement auth in my app this way (to have a separate next_auth schema in my supabase database) although it might not be the best way to do it. Has Auth0 changed it’s ridiculous pricing structure approach yet? I did get it to work in the end though, but wish I knew about Lucia Auth sooner because when searching for alternatives the only thing I could find was enterprise alternatives (e. I'm working on a Next. I have to make a website for a client and was asked to use Clerk for auth. It has everything you need: Email magic link Google OAuth Role Based Access Control View community ranking In the Top 10% of largest communities on Reddit [ Help ] Session returning null - Looking for a a guide for NextJS 13 and auth helpers . Since you already have 12k MAU, I would make the technical investment into Cognito. if someone wants to build their apps using "one size fits all" copy-paste solutions without understanding how they work, it's up to them, but that's certainly not how Google intends you to use its cloud products. dev is definitely new, not perfect, but they are extremely responsive to issues, and are actively contributing to the community to make auth in the react ecosystem as easy as possible. Create a user_id column that defaults to the Clerk user's ID when new records are created. A request is considered “authenticated” when the backend can securely identify the user and device that is making the request. My journey with Clerk Auth has been nothing short of transformative. Learn the fundamentals. To get started, create a header for your users to sign in or out. Social login typically uses Oauth (the spec/standard, not the hosted service), and the access + refresh token mechanisms allow your app to access data about that user (e. The oauth [auth] code flow is the most secure approach but because public clients (SPAs and native apps) can’t secure the client secret they often resort to implicit (less secure) Auth0 is extremely easy to start with compared to some other solutions (there probably are easier to ways too). 500 Mau's a month. They really suck otherwise though. its a bit complicated than next-auth which is direct plug & play but it isn't as complex in terms of schema. So I created a middleware to authenticate the clerk users and assign the user object to the requests. If I had the skills, I wouldn't be using a managed service for auth. I am trying to include only two options to create a user account. Our dashboard makes it really easy to pick Hey all, this is Braden, one of the co-founders of a company called Clerk. My Google-fu has failed me. Strange and good when you don’t need a Add <ClerkProvider> and components to your app. What is the Hey can someone help me with the clerk auth I am having this issue in my website where on the inital load of the website after signing in,getting the userId as null ,therefore not able to acces any routes,but the problem is being solved once i reload the website and im getting the correct value for userId const { sessionClaims } = auth(); const userId = sessionClaims?. Is Clerk‘s pricing really that insane or am I missing something? I mean, the free and hobby tier sound and look very generous at first. This application will serve as your starting point to explore Migrating User Authentication from Supabase to Clerk. You can do this by visiting clerk. 2 and i'm having a hard time making the Auth flow work. Configuring a new Clerk application for Authentication To begin using Clerk, the first step is to create a Clerk account. (by nextauthjs) NodeJS Nextjs OAuth React Authentication Nextauth Csrf JWT Oauth2 Oidc Hi all, I want to use clerk for auth and user management in my product. Clerk. One major feature missing in NextAuth is 2FA/MFA and no username/password login, which has to be implemented yourself. We've completely solved all the cors issues, and a ton of other nonsense devs shouldn't View community ranking In the Top 5% of largest communities on Reddit. Enable webhooks. I’m Zsolt Ero. Additionally, Clerk supports various authentication strategies, such as password login and social authentication, which can be configured seamlessly through the Clerk dashboard. Clerks have a pop upkeep, but pop upkeep isn't affected by the capital-tier efficiency boons. Questions. Additionally, they also have better SAML support as well. js 14, featuring preconfigured integrations with Clerk for authentication, Prisma ORM & Skip to main content. This was working fine until I deleted all the users from the Clerk dashboard and tried to create accounts again to push the user into the database. With the old version, it was very easy because with the authMiddleware, all routes were protected Although, if you have an app that has a lot of users that don't pay anything, Clerk isn't going to be a good option. You also saw how A true behemoth in terms of authentication & authorization. JinSantosAndria • Additional comment actions. Traditional JWT Authentication vs. js, React, Clerk Auth, Supabase, Prisma ORM and more Clerk Authentication in production mode . This article aims to show you how custom user profiles can be built using the Next. I'm trying to make an e-commerce website in react, for authentication I'm trying to use 'clerk' library but for some reason it just wont work. userId as string; Not OP. So there's no added resource expenditure. import { auth } from '@clerk/nextjs' import clerk from '@clerk/clerk-sdk-node' import { google } from 'googleapis' You're going to need to auth to get your userId. We’ll add our auth code, and suddenly we’ll have to sign in to actually see it. Its open-source nature, extensive community Specifically, applications that call auth() in App Router and getAuth() in Page Router. So, after creating all those db stuff, I'm confused which function should I use for the auth (supabaseClient or the signIn function by NextAuth). oidc: authentication, delegates access to identity with an identity token. js with a mobile application Supabase vs. js Clerk SDK. With a couple more hours of effort implementing TOTP 2FA is trivial. Note that in this context the Information and discussion about Azure DevOps, Microsoft's developer collaboration tools helping you to plan smarter, collaborate better, and ship faster with a set of modern dev services. STEP 3: Implementing Clerk Auth in WunderGraph. I finally switched to Kinde Auth, which is practically what I was looking for. I never liked this approach so I avoided it and did the auth with cookies myself. 1. The reasons for making authenticated requests to the backend include: Associating the user with the action being performed; Ensuring the user has permission to make the request; Keeping an audit log of If I was using a service, I would go with Cognito as the free tier is unbeatable, but it's less polished than something like Clerk. Q&A. r/nextjs A chip A close button. js is the Skip to main content. Auth Nice to Haves: PasswordLess (Magic Link) Sign-In January 12th, 2024, Clerk, an authentication and user management solution for web and mobile applications, notified the public about a critical security vulnerability discovered in the @clerk/nextjs SDK. js (but the new docs are too complicated for me and lost my patience), Auth. Interested to hear how you all decide where to go with auth and whether there are any specific features that you're looking for that aren't offered in the market. At one point having 30+ tabs to try and understand this shiz. Passport felt much more natural. They In a recent project, I investigated Clerk, a powerful solution for simplifying user authentication in Next. Get started Explore the docs. I like that it is supposed to work on servers and serverless setups (edge). js application using Clerk for Authentication, and Drizzle ORM with Postgres for Storage A working example is linked in the article but you can also find it here: https://neon-clerk-drizzle-nextjs. They provide MFA I‘ve tried NextAuth and Clerk. I also like Clerks How did I choose which Auth solution to try out? I’ve read a lot of Hacker News and Reddit comments and tried them out in the order presented here. January 12th, 2024, Clerk, an authentication and user management solution for web and mobile applications, notified the public about a critical security vulnerability discovered in the @clerk/nextjs SDK. I want to implement authentication and I was thinking about clerk, the problem is that there is no resource how to handle this between NextJS and Express, have anyone implemented this and can explain ? Ready to Implement Authentication in Your App? Don't hesitate to explore our Next. Oauth2 is a auth. They just want you to use third party auth. If when you check the auth I have a User model with some fields that are not present in clerk and I also want to maintain the data in my own database and not rely on clerk entirely. Hey, So I'm playing around with Vercel Platform Starter Kit (I'm looking at using the layout / setup and make this my own) but wanting to use Clerk Authentication. If you're just need extremely barebones authentication, Amazon, Google, and Microsoft will all do ok, and integrate with their respective stacks to some extent (IIRC MS is the most generous with 50k free users). In a way oauth (underlying) is used to authorize access to the user identity that is retrieved through the OIDC endpoints. Sorry guys. But I'm currently looking into replacing supabase auth for clerk because it's doing weird things for me. I created a full in depth tutorial on how set up authentication with next-auth in just 1 hour 30 minutes. js and sync it with our DB. I’d say clerk is pretty comparable to other auth as service solutions price wise. Heh. After trying NextAuth and Auth. Anyone use Clerk Auth? I am trying to retrieve the logged in user in a route handler like this: import { NextResponse, NextRequest } from Advertisement Coins. I am also using Prisma ORM. Social Login: Enable users to log in with their social media accounts (e. com. Why would someone pay to get the features they already have? Even the repo github link is broken. Shit all you really need is a Postgres DB and a Django install and you’ve got a very good username+password implementation ready to use. Expand user menu Open settings menu. Suggest alternative. UI for both is roughly equivalent. I actually have to do the authentication & authorization architecture of our multi tenancy app at work as my second true professional project. In the do-it-yourself JWT approach, all responsibilities regarding authentication—such as storing the Clerk’s components and auth helpers are purpose-built for the Next. Now, let’s dive into the code and integrate Clerk authentication into our WunderGraph BFF. js Clerk Docs for a quick and comprehensive guide on integrating Clerk’s User Management into your application within minutes, not days. Auth0 is about the same in price. Share Add a Comment. It sounds gatekeepery, but truth is auth is REALLY risky and very commonly poorly implemented. Example: Convex Authentication with Clerk If you're using Next. js App Router, making it intuitive to protect your pages and endpoints behind a secure interface. I sm not sure if we can edit the look and feel but if I got a figma design from client then how do I inplement the same design on Clerk? I am building a NextJS app using the Clerk Authentication, and I am having a big problem with the new Clerk, which is complex than the previous version. Compare clerk-nextjs-starter vs next-auth and see what are their differences. If I ran auth on my own servers, not only do I have to maintain it, but I also have to scale it if my application grows. (Merchants- with a 2 CG job upkeep- go to 2. js, Clerk, I ended up using Kinde Auth. dev Clerk has moved to "clerk". 23. You can use the userId taken from clerk for further API access. I had been struggling to add auth in my project for a while and yesterday I came across Clerk and boy it is good and simple although i have some issues with the docs, it's not vast enough the getting started part is fabulous I added auth to all the routes of my project but now I wanna add some role based routes for which I am not able to find proper explanation, i have got the Using Clerk was a nightmare for us, all it took was 15 active users to start getting ratelimited constantly. They have the opinion that passwordless is the future, however they View community ranking In the Top 1% of largest communities on Reddit. g. js 13 app, and honestly I don't understand how a library that used to be called next-auth, doesn't have, if not complete documentation covering the app router paradigm, at least a fully working example. I chose Next for the web and react native for mobile. Top. Even minor Eartho serves as a privacy-focused layer between users and major authentication providers like Google, Facebook, and others. Hi! Every time I try to use an auth provider, it feels like things become more complicated than building the auth myself. The vulnerability allowed malicious Svelte is a radical new approach to building user interfaces. With the approach growing in popularity, the founders of Clerk decided to focus their startup on building a simplified identity tool purpose-built for React applications. I having a hard time wrapping my head around next-auth library specially due to the documentations being outdated for next 13 and lack of docs for a basic email and password authentication. Every feature you need now and as you scale. This is so expensive. 0 coins. So I Explore the technical differences between Supabase Auth and Clerk for user authentication solutions. dev: A Step-by-Step Guide. js applications. npm install @clerk/nextjs STEP 3: Implementing Clerk Auth in WunderGraph. More posts you may like. Share Hier sollte eine Beschreibung angezeigt werden, diese Seite lässt dies jedoch nicht zu. Has anyone stumbled on a good example I might find useful? I have everything up and working for adding, deleting, editing data on Mongo thanks to excellent documentation. Instant dev environments Issues. In that case, I will just use next-auth or lucia. I have a medium sized e-commerce site: I have about 7-11k MAU a month Does Skip to main content. Personally I use clerk. I've always hated building auth and related user management features, and Skip to main content. Log In / Sign Up; Advertise on Reddit; Shop Hey guys, I'm about to work on a project that requires a web app and a mobile app. Trusted by security-conscious Next. Related Topics Vue. I enjoy Supabase the most as its gives me all the freedom I need and feels most aligned with next js 13 app router the other. I've def felt your pain before, and it's why I started https://clerk. I believe the Supabase auth helpers use cookies with httpOnly set to false. Zsolt Ero. their social name, social account ID, maybe email - depends entirely on what permissions you request for in terms of scope) stored by the provider (e. Read more comments sorted by Best Top New Controversial Q&A Add a Comment. With Clerk, it feels like I can finally put my days of struggling with auth behind me. Or check it out in the app stores &nbsp; &nbsp; TOPICS. Clerk looks really promising but I'm afraid to commit as I feel I'll be locked in with whatever provider I choose. io or propelauth - but none of them right now supports Deno ootb. After 4 attemps with email signup, the dashboard says I've done more than 30, and that's with their own Next starter project, I feel like I didn't even had I am working on a Next. plus unlike the other libraries you mentioned above like auth0, firebase, & clerk, you don't have to outsource your auth. But authentication has been the most complex thing for me, atleast it was before next auth. Top 7% The prior article examined how Clerk may simplify user authentication for Next. The pre built pages of Next Auth also went unused by our team because we needed to roll a custom UI to match the rest of our app. dev - auth "should just work". If I can't easily understand both the code and docs I can't trust it. Comparing Auth from Supabase, Firebase, Auth. So if you need something very flexible and extensive, consider using Cognito (or other cloud alternative) I’m using clerk for authentication and there’s a user icon in the header. You can open an issue, but if the problem is non-compliance with the spec, we might not pursue a resolution. It's pretty sad that it's supposed to be the defacto auth framework for nextjs. I’ve managed to adapt that to register new users, however, I only have 2 (out of 13) that I actually pay for because they’re high-traffic apps. I am an unsure how I should integrate auth and asking for your advice. Adding Clerk auth to Next + GraphQL apps with Exograph. The following example demonstrates how to use the useAuth() hook to access the current auth state, like whether the user is signed in or not. They are sponsoring Auth. Write better code with AI Security. 9 sla in that tier and MFA not below If you aren't an expert at auth NEVER run your own auth. app/ Reply reply Top 1% Rank by size . Share this post. production i ve faced many problems in the configuration of clerk particularly in the DNS , and i got a blank screen, note that's my final app is in form APK , My question is how i Clerk on the other hand is great, simple to integrate, however MFA costs 100$ a month, which is a no-go. I created an expo react native app recently which uses clerk for authentication and it works seamlessly during testing but when I build an apk using eas build and install the apk on either my emulator or a physical android phone, the app just does not go beyond the sign in Convex & Clerk. Facebook. If you look at Passportjs Commit History you'll quickly notice that all they do by now is update sponsors or change to docs. The oauth [auth] code flow is the most secure approach but because public clients (SPAs and native apps) can’t secure the client secret they often resort to implicit (less secure) The guys over at next auth don't want you writing your own auth. dev it’s like Auth0 but easier,faster to integrate. View plans and pricing for Clerk’s developer tools for authentication. ClerkExpressWithAuth() ClerkExpressWithAuth() is a lax middleware that returns an empty auth object when an unauthenticated request is made. js setup guide. ) serverside app could do it. It's also Developing a secure and robust authentication system requires a deep understanding of security principles, cryptographic protocols, and best practices. Thank you! Steps to sync clerk users to your database Here's a step-by-step guide to syncing users from Clerk to your database. js project that uses Clerk for the authentication and Supabase as the database. Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. Today, we'll examine and contrast Clerk and NextAuth. View community ranking In the Top 1% of largest communities on Reddit. 10,000 monthly active users free. I am trying to protect all my routes, but make the "/api" routes public so that I can fetch the data from the server side. For the example, we’ll use the default page that was already created by the generator. Log In / Sign Up; Advertise on Reddit; Shop Configuring Clerk for authentication by setting up Social SSO, password-based authentication, email magic links, and multifactor authentication via SMS passcodes. Best way to do auth with Next + Node JS App? Any help or directing me towards a tutorial would be great! Thanks <3 I know how to do it in Node, I've seen it done in NextJS, but I'm not sure how to do them both together comments sorted by Best Top New Controversial Q&A Add a Comment I am using it. 16. Swapping say, your text or email provider when it gets too pricey and/or there's a better alternative is no big deal but auth can be a very complicated. Next Auth sucks with App Routes. The question is, is next-auth a good solution for my project? As I don't know what the limitation of next-auth is for credentials providers. You can't even export/transfer all your users to another auth provider or db. Initially, it's going to work only with OAuth providers. It's cumbersome in the least or downright annoying to set it up with any custom authentication because I never found their docs good. Surprisingly simple, exceptionally powerful. Premium Powerups Explore Gaming. NFL But I have to add something about the Auth functionality: Currently Supabase only allows OAuth2 with some popular providers and creates one User table per Application. Copy link. I don't have much backend experience but Im trying to do something I would have thought should be easy. js developers at companies you recognize like Turso, Inngest, BaseHub, and others. Was hoping it would be easy to use with Clerk js, but cannot find any examples for how to integrate. Valheim Genshin Impact Minecraft Pokimane Halo Infinite Call of Duty: Warzone Path of Exile Hollow Knight: Silksong Escape from Tarkov Watch Dogs: In my example below, I use the gmail scope, so add it from your clerk dashboard. The vulnerability allowed malicious Hier sollte eine Beschreibung angezeigt werden, diese Seite lässt dies jedoch nicht zu. Auth Implementation for Next. 6 CG. At least one accessibility-focused non-commercial third party app will continue to be available free of charge. But I use Clerk Auth so I don't know how to set Row Level Security and without that I'm not able to upload files to Supabase. Auth Restrictions: I do want productivity and velocity, but not so much that I jump to Auth Providers (easiest option). So after talking on Reddit, I was recommended a product (It's open source) here in the comment section. How to use the useAuth() hook. Whereas traditional frameworks like React and Vue do the bulk of their work in the browser, Svelte shifts that work into a compile step that happens when you build your app. Clerk’s post-mortem is not very transparent about the details of the vulnerability. Log In / Sign Up; Advertise I have used Next-Auth but no much into depth, implemented basic OAuth so cannot write much but have worked with supabase’s auth (not part of this discussion though) and it’s nice one, used OAuth as well as email-password authentication, they’ve two main packages“supabase-auth-helpers” and a new one “supabase-ssr” a better approach. I don't know if I should use a third-party auth solution like Clerk and if any of those solutions has solid support for both Next and React Native, or if I should just implement custom auth. I've encountered a requirement where my middleware needs to check the authentication provider used by the user during sign-in. I've tried using auth0 as an alternative then I realized you have to pay for your own db so switched to next auth I have a MongoDB using mongoose that has data on ideally, id like to use this but I can't find any good documentation anywhere! I've made it a question so its easier to read than on a Reddit comment any help appreciated. blog. Clerk provides a handy managed service option, but it's wise to weigh your options before making a choice. js 14 (app dir) and an separate/external Backend? 1. Great tool, I use it on the work and for all of my setup at home. That is, Firebase Auth only charges for sending texts to users to verify and Hi all, right now there are tons of auth providers from big ones like Auth0 and Clerk to more nice niche players like logto. Email. NFL I created a full in depth tutorial on how set up authentication with next-auth in just 1 hour 30 minutes. The prior article examined how Clerk may simplify user authentication for Next. I have not seen an example of auth. So I decided to create my solution: Pie Auth. js app and I've been decently happy with Next Auth. Might take a couple of days to a week, to understand everything but this is something you'll need to understand at some Scenario - user deletes their account and consequently on clerk too. My goal is to prevent users from accessing the dashboard until they've connected their TikTok account. Let me explain the context: sometimes I have jobs in which I need OAuth integrations, such as Spotify, Deezer, and Facebook. It has everything you need: Email magic link Google OAuth Role Based Access Control Authentication with clerk I'm doing authentication with clerk although I didn't find any real helpful documentation about it, basically I need to have three roles user, admin and editor also should I to do all my authentication stuff in the front as clerk will handle everything for me or should I integrate in my backend What you describe with the client side auth and sending the token to the server is what Supabase suggests. I view it as paying for auth that scales and comes with support. How do people implement user authentication using Astro? Say I want private routes and private blog posts. js 14 and External Backend: - What is the best way to implement an Auth for Next. Sports. I had a sign-in button which, when clicked, would redirect the user to the Clerk sign-in page. How to approach this? Could not find SDK or documentation anywhere. Automate any workflow Codespaces. It provides more than authentication; you can manage users, sessions, APIs, and more right from the Clerk dashboard. With just a few steps, you will learn to prepare your Clerk. js, to help you decide which is ideal for your project. I’m talking auth in a few lines of code. Sort by: Best. Create policies to restrict what data can be read and inserted. Product; Docs; Changelog; Pricing; Company; Pricing that scales with you . Authentication requires user input, usually collected via redirection to authentication pages such as the sign-up or sign-in page. 15 votes, 34 comments. Reply reply SilentLeadership3996 • I have the same issue Reply reply Top 2% Rank by size . I am working on a Next. Very simple and straightforward to implement, good docs and you get 10. For more in-depth technical inquiries or to engage with our community, feel free to join our Discord. milkboxshow • Additional comment actions. I’ve set it up in nextjs. Note. dev environment, extract user data from Supabase, and programmatically create users in Clerk. clerkinc has one repository available. , If you’re using broadly used crypto and auth libraries there is little risk in using a home grown auth solution. 💡 I will be making reference to the clerk docs but I will also add some extra steps. When users log in using Eartho, they can still There are lots of different ways to configure sign up and sign in - password vs passwordless, email vs phone vs username, oauth vs no oauth. ) Clerks/Trade Builds actually win on the conversion exchange, because trade builds produce CG without needing minerals, whereas the efficiency boons require more minerals for artisan-CG. Backed by Stripe, a16z, and more. Your system thinks they 2 different people, but they're not (if you're using auth_id from clerk). Doesn't seem like this lib is (well) maintained at all at the moment, which would be the main reason for me not to go for it. More This is my first time trying to spin up an authentication system using next. Supabase vs Clerk vs Kinde Auth Hey everyone! I'm working on my first RN Expo App and would like to implement authentication for the app if someone has experience with these services. You will need your own Google Credentials with ClientID and secret set on the clerk dashboard aswell. Auth for B2C and B2B SaaS: build it yourself (better control) vs 3rd party . An expiration date is just a timestamp thats associated with the Auth token as soon as its made, mine is 6 hours after the auth token is posted, and a timeout timestamp would update each time auth is checked, mine is 15 minutes, but more sensitive applications should be much shorter timeouts, possibly even using websockets rather than a rest api. You'll have to learn how to work with their components/pages if NextAuth. You can control which content signed in and signed out users can see with Clerk's prebuilt components. What's up with those auth providers, 99$ per month, not even 99. the libary must include: username/email and password auth and google oauth The front end developer wants to use Clerk for auth. Wait until you're an expert, then do it - and then it's a really good option for The app I'm working on right now is a Next. Free plan. Advanced Features of CLERK Beyond basic authentication, CLERK offers several advanced features: Multi-Factor Authentication (MFA): Add an extra layer of security by enabling MFA. Why Clerk I am building a NextJS app using the Clerk Authentication, and I am having a big problem with the new Clerk, which is complex than the previous version. Help I'm currently working on an app using Next. Log In / Sign Up; Advertise Supabase Auth vs Clerk Discussion I dont know if using supabase or clerk is better, I have an app wich I want to scale it big, and try to hit at least 10k active users, which one do you think is better and not too expensive to use, and if you know another better option, please let me know Supabase vs. It depends a lot on what you're looking for in an auth provider for any specific project. Now, after signup, the user is required to go Skip to main content. For information about the User operations available, such as getUser() , createUser() , and deleteUser() , check out the Backend SDK reference docs . So in Golang's case, Buffalo. Cognito is cheap, but Best way for Integrating Authentication Providers like Clerk or Kinde with Next. My question is, will I have this same success for Auth on the CLI app? I'm a big fan of Clerk and know that they have Expo integration, but is it possible to use the service in the application? Is Expo modules enough to get me running? If not, what else do I have to consider and what resources can you point me towards? Thank you. View community ranking In the Top 20% of largest communities on Reddit. 1. Here are my auth If you aren't an expert at auth NEVER run your own auth. Anyone that has to ask these questions isn't ready to run their own auth. The docs state: "The functionality provided for credentials based authentication is intentionally limited to discourage use of passwords due to the inherent security risks associated with them and the additional complexity associated with supporting Auth needs to be understandable - NextAuth/Auth. comments sorted by Best Top New Controversial Q&A Add a Comment. Hi, I am currently working on my Go backend template. Jack Herrington on YouTube has a good next auth setup breakdown in nextjs 13 that should help. Valheim Genshin Impact Minecraft Pokimane Halo Infinite Call of Duty: Warzone Path of Exile Hollow Knight: Silksong Escape from Tarkov Watch Dogs: Legion. Well, yeah - login with username and password is typically manageable without using a webview in most auth services. Follow their code on GitHub. Same email but now its with a different auth_id. Cheers! The JavaScript Backend SDK exposes Clerk's backend API resources and low-level authentication utilities for JavaScript environments. The I'm enjoying Next Auth immensely, apart from one aspect: Next Auth is intentionally limiting the credentials provider. The first step was to bootstrap a The other thing worth noting is that for the free tiers, clerk offers 5,000 MAU whereas auth0 offers 7,000. clerk-nextjs-starter. If you want to express your strong disagreement with the API pricing Create a function in Supabase to parse the Clerk user ID from the authentication token. Feb 16, 2023. Hello everyone, im using clerk service for login with my expo application, my app works perfectly in development mode , but when i change the publish key for. Hey guys, I'm about to work on a project that requires a web app and a mobile app. Look up the users data in I view it as paying for auth that scales and comes with support. Supabase Auth is a robust authentication solution that integrates seamlessly with Keycloak isn't an auth solution (at least in the way of having app integrations or an SDK), it's an identity manager. Top 7% I've to agree and I m doing the same, i have gone from next auth -> clerk -> supabase. It has everything you need: Email magic link Google OAuth Role Based Access Control TL;DR In this tutorial we’ll show you how to use add authentication to your full stack application using Clerk. If jwt should not be used in authentication then a authorization code flow which is used for SPA apps for example, should not be even developed. Then they re-register and clerk produces another user_id. Next, you need to create an OAuth Application in Clerk via the Backend API by providing the Callback URL and a Name. r/reactjs A chip A close button. js (by clerkinc) Authentication React Nextjs clerk. I have a few questions about Clerk Auth If I may. exograph. Navigation Menu Toggle navigation. Here are my auth Setup vs code debugger and put some debugger statements on each callback in next auth to understand what is being called and when. Client Requests Auth Server -> Handles Auth -> Updates Session -> Sends Cookie You can reject it at any time, you can track it in your DB, and unless you're lax on security, you're making those requests anyway. Supabase already provides all their features out of the box. Supabase developer here. dev: Comparative Analysis of Auth Tools felixvemmer. Be the first to comment Nobody's responded to this post yet. I lose full control over my database schema, I have to deal with the challenges of using the library or an auth provider, making things work the way I want them to almost always leads to some workarounds, as I have to deal with limitations of the library. Several developers of commercial third-party apps have announced that this change will compel them to shut down their apps. Use the Clerk Supabase integration helper in your code to authenticate with Supabase and execute queries. the libary must include: username/email and password auth and google oauth View community ranking In the Top 5% of largest communities on Reddit. Cheers! Anyone use Clerk Auth? I am trying to retrieve the logged in user in a route handler like this: import { NextResponse, NextRequest } from Advertisement Coins. New. Passwordless Authentication: Allow users to log in without a password using email or SMS links. Developers know that adding authentication to an application is a mundane and tedious task and they increasingly choose to outsource it. I couldn't find much online explaining how to have a secure authentication system for my app other than the quick-start JWT guides or Auth0. Jwt is data format. Reply reply GhostLexly • next-auth Is there any way Clerk offers multiple authentication strategies to identify legitimate users of your application, and to allow them to make authenticated requests to your backend. Cognito is most comparable to something like Firebase Authentication IMHO. Get app Get the Reddit app Log In Log in to Reddit. com) Clerk: More than authentication, Complete user management Auth0 is extremely easy to start with compared to some other solutions (there probably are easier to ways too). This might become my I was using Auth. Open comment sort options. js API routes as my backend, Prisma ORM for database management, and considering integrating authentication with Clerk Authentication not showing up Help I'm coding a webapp with next js and I follow all the steps to implement clerk authentification but when I reload the page I never get acces to the authentification page, and I try with different projects and it still not working what can I do ? ps: I've checked the keys and the middleware but nothing working oidc: authentication, delegates access to identity with an identity token. js, Ory, Clerk and others Looking at Auth providers from a software developer's perspective. Edit details. For example, with Supabase auth, once a user is authenticated, then access to any database or storage or realtime features are automatically restricted by the capabilities you've granted to the logged-in user, which can save considerable time in Add social auth providers (eg: Google), working perfectly with my backend and frontend. The Clerk is an authentication platform providing login via passwords, social identity providers, one-time email or SMS access codes, and multi-factor authentication and basic user management. js (hopefully with a Nuxt module) seems to become the best way to handle auth without a third-party provider (like Auth0 or Clerk). Node SDK Middleware. dev. Please what do I do? If this info is of any help: I'm using Next. Please if anyone know how to do this or figures it out, the help would be much appreciated. Wait until you're an expert, then do it - and then it's a really good option for Just a quick question regarding auth, I’ve been reading into some frameworks for auth and it seems like passport. Best. How would you implement Authorization for a Web Api backend if the front end is React using Clerk for authentication? Was thinking about using Auth0 but have been reading a lot in the last week about Clerk and Stytch, as well as a few other new Startups that aim to provide authentication and authorization. Find and fix vulnerabilities Actions. Everything you need to get I think it's only for side projects because of how it looks. How can I do that? I am using Mongoose with Mongo DB. js strictly adheres to the specification and it cannot take responsibility for any deviation from the spec by the provider. js apps, I figure why not port over the site to Next at the same time to learn both platforms. Hi everybody! I'm building an app with NextJS 13. Clerk ( https: View community ranking In the Top 1% of largest communities on Reddit. github. Auth0 SDK for NextJS v2. The Clerk Node SDK offers two authentication middlewares specifically for Express and Connect/Express compatible frameworks such as Fastify. Maybe clerk? Reply reply (specially when we're talking about authentication), that's why people spend years learning about software development. Official starter repo for Clerk and Next. View community ranking In the Top 5% of largest communities on Reddit. Scenario - user deletes their account and consequently on clerk too. Share. vercel. r/nextjs • Why i will cancel my vercel pro subscribtion See, to be honest, getting errors doesn't mean you should look for alternatives, getting it to work isn't easy too, I have experienced it. js application where I'm using Clerk for user authentication. I love it honestly, there were some annoying things I had an issue with when compared to Firebase, like native Auth, but they recently added native Apple Login support and soon they plan on adding Google auth support. To enable webhooks, go to the Webhooks page in the Clerk dashboard and click on the Add Endpoint button. u/bsclerk: Co-founder and CTO of Clerk (https://www. For the example, we'll use the default page that was already created by the generator. you dont even need to get NodeJS involved for auth. If you're just building a demo project kind of thing or an app which has less than 5k MAUs, you should definitely check-out clerk as it is extremely easy to setup (even with the new app router), but if you have large user base, I would not advise you to use clerk. We'll add our auth code, and suddenly we'll have to sign in to actually see it. Basically the reason why recently we started to see the rise of Clerk and Authkit, is exactly because there is a demand for easy to use auth, that solves a typical things you need while building almost any app. I get these warnings on chrome 'Third-party cookie will be blocked' and last week my clerk authentication wouldn't work on chrome but in edge there was no problem and it actually worked then, now it's Request authentication. Posted by u/Suspicious_Muscle396 - No votes and no comments On July 1st, a change to Reddit's API pricing will come into effect. This guide assumes you already have a working React I'm trying to set RLS so that I can be able to let users of my site upload files to Supabase. Get started . Firebase Auth is free as long as you have fewer than 10k phone users signing in per month. next-auth. 0 released! Let's explore the main features of the new Auth0 SDK for NextJS release. dev or Firebase auth. Clerk is great and I would use it for everything but auth is one of the few services I don't have the opinion of just worrying about cost for scale down the road. But actually the pricing is insane: The free tier allows for In short, it's because Clerk handles both authentication and session management. Reply reply Auth0 can do for you a very complex & complete auth system in a minute but the custmozation is more complex and some things can not be achieved. I'm using Clerk for auth and Prisma for my ORM. hyperknot. com Open. I wouldn’t count suppabase or firebase auth as their auth solutions are meant to be part of a backend as a service solution, not a standalone auth solution. Sign in clerkinc. I'd only use them Next-auth supports credentials as a provider but they also stated here that it is intentionally limited to discourage the use of passwords due to the inherent security risks. I think I have seen examples with flutter for both clerk and Supabase. Not an end-all solution by any means, but I'd say it covers the authentication needs of like 80% of apps out there. Product GitHub Copilot. Other. I guarantee you you'll miss something. clerk. I don't use credentials authentication. js is a compelling alternative to Clerk, offering developers greater control, flexibility, and cost-effectiveness. Thank you! The scenario that you recall, calling service from other service (service-to-service) scenario is performed which 2-leg auth (aka client credential flow). Heavily against expensive auth providers like Okta Auth0, AWS Cognito, etc. I’m in the midst of a MERN stack app with React 18 and having trouble finding good examples of modern login/auth for it. js. For Lucia Auth I only did a technology assessment, they provide a library for MFA, however auth flow and UI would have to be done by yourself. Clerk, Supabase, or even a basic node, PHP, python (etc. Their components are so easy to use, basically 0 backend, unless you need it. bevmj vpdhj zwjfyw ltol dehwc rddrw wcd gwmk rraf usmx